Bah, i dont think so, however I hope u'll define exactly later this situation... thanks bye

Bah, i dont think so, however I hope u'll define exactly later this situation... thanks bye

easiest way to be sure so you can be happy in your own mind is watch both the replays and keep an eye on the turn counter. (can post them on here if u'd like other people's views.)

It's not a question of happiness of mind Enforcer, but who take decisions have always to give the reason about it....!
Ive seen the replay of the games, it s the first thing i done naturally, and its for this reason that i think Keule must prove what he said...and let the moderators judge
bye

It's not a question of happiness of mind Enforcer, but who take decisions have always to give the reason about it....!
Ive seen the replay of the games, it s the first thing i done naturally, and its for this reason that i think Keule must prove what he said...and let the moderators judge
bye

i dont know why it show my post 2times.............

Tournament manager shows you winning in 14 turns while Keule won in 12.

u are wrong mwigor, it show 14turns cause we sent msg eachother after my victory in 12turn

Some more results are in.

Tywer won his 3-way match and takes his place in the undefeated pool.

The following Round 1b matches are underway

Winners
24 NikTheKid v 41 tomhahnl
27 Chikitos v 59 Nharkor

Losers
38 Donut v 70 skomo
56 adiabatic v 73 General Rojo

This will cause a problem if it is the case. Please send both replays to mwigor@yahoo.com.au

I think, we both won in turn 12 (that's shown in the replays).
But I destroyed more units and had got more survivors. That's why I won.
Endstats (army/casualities): Round 1 guderian27: 49/37 Keule: 8/72
Round 2 guderian27: 4/82 Keule: 59/43
Like I said: It was close

Keule

here is the replay

the other one show that i ve won in 11turn.......not in 12.
Sorry for the polemics but i think to be right

Hi guderian27,

now really watch the reps. Both end in turn 12. But the game I won ends with YOUR 12th turn. My 12th isn't shown
I won with FNU (as you did). FNU always has the 2nd turn.
Just watch 'em and at the turn counter. Don't look at the file name.

will this arguement ever end

Hopefully this will be the final word!

My viewing of the replays is as follows.

Both players won on turn 12 as green. The next tiebreak is units destroyed.

Keule destroyed $77 + $37 = $114
guderian27 destroyed $72 + $43 = $115

Therefore guderian27 won this match.

Sorry for misleading you Keule.

Cheers, MW.

Dang, 1$ difference! Can't get any closer than that

Apologies again - the replays posted don't include Keule's last turn in the game he won - in which he destroyed an additional $5 of troops. Therefore Keule won this match.

rofl are we sure this is the end now. either way looks like a very nice pair of games.

Some more results.

CrimeGorilla and nblawat have secured their places in the undefeated pool in Round 2.

The following Round 1b games have been started.

Winners Enforcer v eisbaer
Losers Pinkasso v ManOwaR